TODAY’S LEAD · NHL
The Leafs Report
Toronto's special-teams record from last season is the standard Tuesday puts on trial.
Toronto's special-teams record from last season is the standard Tuesday puts on trial. The Leafs ran a 21.3% power play and an 81.2% penalty kill across 82 games — numbers that kept them in the middle of the league rather than contending for position in the Atlantic. Those figures are a decision: how many times does a team accept being mediocre on the man-advantage before the structure changes? The 1-4 home loss to Montréal on September 19 is the relevant data point. Montréal finished last season at 23.1% on the power play — nearly two full percentage points ahead of Toronto — while holding a 106-point finish that placed them well clear of this club. William Nylander's 79 points and John Tavares's 31 goals require a power play that converts; without it, the offence stays 5-on-5 dependent. Scotiabank Arena on Tuesday is the first real test of whether anything changed.
THE DEEP DIVE
Toronto's power play converted at 21.3% last season — league-middling, unremarkable, not the problem. The penalty kill at 81.2% is the structural drain, and it compounds a goals-against rate that ranked 31st of 32 clubs last season at 3.65 per game. Special teams did not merely underperform; they accelerated a structural deficit. When your PK is leaking and your 5-on-5 goaltending posted an 89.7% save percentage, every minor penalty becomes a compounding event. The 21.3% PP cannot offset that math.
Montréal's completed 2025-26 season complicates the picture in a specific way. They killed penalties at 78.2% — worse than Toronto's 81.2% — which means the Leafs' power play, limited as it is, arrives Tuesday with a genuine edge. Montréal also scored 3.4 goals per game last season against a league-average backdrop, so their offence is real. The condition under which Toronto's special teams situation worsens: Montréal's 23.1% PP from last season is the sharper unit. If Toronto's PK surrenders early in the regular-season opener at Scotiabank Arena, the deficit erases whatever PP advantage the Leafs might manufacture through William Nylander's production — 30 goals and 49 assists last season, accounting for a disproportionate share of what this offence generates.
The Playbook expects Toronto's PK rate to be the first confirmed signal of whether last season's 81.2% figure holds or deteriorates against a Montréal power play that converted at 23.1% last season. If Montréal scores on two or more power plays Tuesday, expect the goals-against rate — already 3.65 per game last season — to frame the narrative for this team's early weeks.